New Statesman - Gay rights and "cultural relativism"
Gay rights and "cultural relativism"
Petra Davis
Published 05 November 2009
A response to Peter Tatchell
"[A] big error by some multiculturalists has been to bow to demands for cultural sensitivity by tacitly accepting that some peoples and communities can be exempt from the norms of universal human rights," argues the veteran lesbian, gay, bisexual and transgender (LGBT) campaigner Peter Tatchell in the Independent today.
Tatchell's piece is an excerpt from his talk "Multiculturalism: the Subversion of Human Rights?", given as part of the Glasgay! festival. Citing the conspicuous lack of protections for LGBT people in equality legislation, Tatchell made the case that multiculturalism is leading to the rights of some minorities being prized over those of others. He also alleged complicity from those whose wariness of accusations of racism and Islamophobia could readily be exploited by the religious right, and argues that human rights activists have a moral duty to intervene in one another's cultures to establish universal human rights.
Tatchell's central contention -- that multiculturalism should not equal cultural relativism -- is shared by the activist and campaigner Linda Bellos. "Cultural relativism is destructive," she agrees. "It sets up a hierarchy of oppression, a kind of competition in which one minority group seeks to claim that it is more oppressed than another. In actual fact, most people have a set of identities that are multiple -- so, for example, there are many black people who are also lesbian, gay, bisexual, or transgender, and I'm one of those people. For us, setting up a hierarchy of oppression means there's always conflict."
Bellos does take some issue with Tatchell's interventionism, however. "He shouldn't be working on our behalf -- he should be working with us," she argues. "I continue to take issue with the lack of respect he seems to have for the work already being done."
Bellos may have a point. During his talk, Tatchell discussed the importance of his engagement with organisations such as the Muslim Council of Britain, but mentioned none of the UK's black and Muslim LGBT organisations. No mention was made of Black Pride, of UK Black Out, or the Black Gay Men's Advisory Group, with which Tatchell has previously worked very successfully on the Stop Murder Music! campaign and the Reggae Compassionate Act.
The tensions Tatchell explores in his talk are manifest, but there is still room for dialogue. This will naturally involve sometimes painful criticisms of others; but perhaps the work is best done in co-operation with, not on behalf of, LGBT people from different communities.
Wednesday, 11 November 2009
Glasgow's transsexual Jesus | Culture | The Guardian
Glasgow's transsexual Jesus | Culture | The Guardian
Glasgow's transsexual Jesus
Charlotte Higgins
Tuesday 10 November 2009
Two hundred Christian protesters picketed the Tron theatre in Glasgow last week on the opening night of Jo Clifford's play Jesus Queen of Heaven, which depicts Christ as a transsexual. It sounds as if the protesters were at least as entertaining as the play, part of the city's Glasgay! festival. One placard read: "God: 'My son is not a pervert.'" I'm wondering by what means God might have imparted this message (telephone interview?).
Glasgow's transsexual Jesus
Charlotte Higgins
Tuesday 10 November 2009
Two hundred Christian protesters picketed the Tron theatre in Glasgow last week on the opening night of Jo Clifford's play Jesus Queen of Heaven, which depicts Christ as a transsexual. It sounds as if the protesters were at least as entertaining as the play, part of the city's Glasgay! festival. One placard read: "God: 'My son is not a pervert.'" I'm wondering by what means God might have imparted this message (telephone interview?).
Monday, 9 November 2009
Christians protest at portrayal of Jesus as transsexual woman - Herald Scotland | News | Home News
Christians protest at portrayal of Jesus as transsexual woman - Herald Scotland | News | Home News
Readers should note the correction at the end of this article by The Herald. A FACTUAL INACCURACY with regard to THE SH[OUT] EXHIBITION REFERRED TO AS "MADE IN GODS IMAGE" was remoned. THE ORIGINAL WRONGLY ATTRIBUTED TO EXHIBITION AS THE FESTIVAL'S OWN WORK. The EXHIBITION was produced by artists funded by Culture & Sport Glasgow and such artists did not feature in or have anything to do with the Glasgay festival.
Readers should note the correction at the end of this article by The Herald. A FACTUAL INACCURACY with regard to THE SH[OUT] EXHIBITION REFERRED TO AS "MADE IN GODS IMAGE" was remoned. THE ORIGINAL WRONGLY ATTRIBUTED TO EXHIBITION AS THE FESTIVAL'S OWN WORK. The EXHIBITION was produced by artists funded by Culture & Sport Glasgow and such artists did not feature in or have anything to do with the Glasgay festival.
Saturday, 7 November 2009
Friday, 6 November 2009
Jeus Queen of Heaven, sh[out] exhibition & Made in God's Image
THE GLASGAY! FESTIVAL WISHES TO POINT OUT TO READERS A FACTUAL INACCURACY with regard to the following quote appearing in recent news and blogs "Glasgay!, which is supported by the city council quango Culture and Sport Glasgow, has already provoked outrage over an exhibition that encouraged the public to graffiti a Bible." !!!! CORRECTION !!!! Readers should note that Glasgay! had nothing to do with the Sh[out] exhibition’s Bible “Made In God’s Image” work which is referred to incorrectly here. This work was made by other Culture & Sport funded artists who have nothing to do with Glasgay!.
Glasgay and Shout exhibition did however co-fund Jo Clifford’s new theatrical play “Jesus Queen of Heaven” which is a literary work of fiction exploring the artists own personal journey of faith as a transgendered person. Glasgay! supports the right to freedom of expression and offers audiences a diverse view of LGBT life. This work is not intended to incite or offend anyone of any belief system however we respect your right to disagree with that opinion. We welcome genuinely interested audience members who wish to understand the artistic intention behind this work.
Glasgay and Shout exhibition did however co-fund Jo Clifford’s new theatrical play “Jesus Queen of Heaven” which is a literary work of fiction exploring the artists own personal journey of faith as a transgendered person. Glasgay! supports the right to freedom of expression and offers audiences a diverse view of LGBT life. This work is not intended to incite or offend anyone of any belief system however we respect your right to disagree with that opinion. We welcome genuinely interested audience members who wish to understand the artistic intention behind this work.
Thursday, 5 November 2009
Theatre review: Jesus, Queen of Heaven - Scotsman.com Living
Theatre review: Jesus, Queen of Heaven - Scotsman.com Living
Theatre review: Jesus, Queen of Heaven
Date: 05 November 2009
By Jay Richardson
JESUS, QUEEN OF HEAVEN **
THE TRON, GLASGOW
IT'S been over 2,000 years, but Jesus still pulls a crowd. The mere existence of this play, in which the Messiah is portrayed as a transsexual woman, prompted more than 300 protesters to demonstrate outside the theatre on opening night. Inside, in a
ADVERTISEMENTset recalling The Last Supper, the audience sat disciple-like around writer-performer Jo Clifford, who, in the title role, began by archly lamenting Christ's apparent habit of upsetting Christians.
At once an expression of faith denouncing fundamentalism, a call for tolerance and acceptance for all, and an unabashed celebration of transgender existence, the worthy Queen of Heaven is regrettably overburdened by its ambition and a central characterisation that could inspire no-one. With the patronising rhetoric of a faux-naif, at times irritatingly New Agey in her wishy-washy evocation of guardian angels, Clifford's Jesus recalls various parables from the New Testament but transplants them to a contemporary setting and recasts them with greater inclusivity – the Good Samaritan is now a disco queen tottering home on her heels; the Prodigal Son returns a Prodigal Daughter.
Parallels between Christ's persecution and that of the transgender community and women are well-drawn and Clifford's version of Christianity feels like a fluffier, more welcoming and indeed fun sect than many. But the playwright can't resolve the Bible's contradictions and this pick'n'mix interpretation, alternately affirming and subverting the Gospels, is ultimately unsatisfying.
Theatre review: Jesus, Queen of Heaven
Date: 05 November 2009
By Jay Richardson
JESUS, QUEEN OF HEAVEN **
THE TRON, GLASGOW
IT'S been over 2,000 years, but Jesus still pulls a crowd. The mere existence of this play, in which the Messiah is portrayed as a transsexual woman, prompted more than 300 protesters to demonstrate outside the theatre on opening night. Inside, in a
ADVERTISEMENTset recalling The Last Supper, the audience sat disciple-like around writer-performer Jo Clifford, who, in the title role, began by archly lamenting Christ's apparent habit of upsetting Christians.
At once an expression of faith denouncing fundamentalism, a call for tolerance and acceptance for all, and an unabashed celebration of transgender existence, the worthy Queen of Heaven is regrettably overburdened by its ambition and a central characterisation that could inspire no-one. With the patronising rhetoric of a faux-naif, at times irritatingly New Agey in her wishy-washy evocation of guardian angels, Clifford's Jesus recalls various parables from the New Testament but transplants them to a contemporary setting and recasts them with greater inclusivity – the Good Samaritan is now a disco queen tottering home on her heels; the Prodigal Son returns a Prodigal Daughter.
Parallels between Christ's persecution and that of the transgender community and women are well-drawn and Clifford's version of Christianity feels like a fluffier, more welcoming and indeed fun sect than many. But the playwright can't resolve the Bible's contradictions and this pick'n'mix interpretation, alternately affirming and subverting the Gospels, is ultimately unsatisfying.
Theatre reviews: The Maw Broon Monologues/10,000 Metres Deep/Antigone - Scotsman.com Living
Theatre reviews: The Maw Broon Monologues/10,000 Metres Deep/Antigone - Scotsman.com Living
Theatre reviews: The Maw Broon Monologues
Maw Broon, catching up after 60 years in limbo with everything the 21st century has to offer.
Date: 05 November 2009
By Joyce McMillan
THE MAW BROON MONOLOGUES ****
TRON THEATRE, GLASGOW
FOR a woman who first saw the light of day on 8 March 1936 – and was a lusty 50-year-old even then – the Sunday Post's great Scottish cartoon matriarch, Maw Broon, is looking in pretty good shape. She's not slim, she's not young, she's not braw; and as she comes to realise, in the course of The Maw Broon Monologues, a new Glasgay! Commission by Glasgow-born poet and playwright Jackie Kay, she isn't actually real.
For all her disadvantages, though, Maw Broon – as personified here by fabulous Terry Neason, and black alter ego Suzanne Bonnar – is all woman; and in Kay's weird, slightly mind-blowing tartan-tinged fantasy, she takes umbrage at Paw Broon's suspected infidelity, and sets off from her kitsch room-and-kitchen at No 10 Glebe Street to travel the world of the early 21st century, in search of the personal fulfilment she deserves.
Tartan shopping bag in hand, and headscarf tied firmly in place, she therefore visits a shrink, tries colonic irrigation, pines for a room of her own, wins through to round three of Scotland's Got Talent ("reality's no just on TV, ye know"), discusses the possible merits of a gay lifestyle, and generates her own version of the Vagina Monologues. And meantime, at the piano, the astonishing Tom Urie – in the character of Maw's unattractive bearded daughter, Daphne Broon – rattles out his own cycle of songs in which Neason and Bonnar celebrate or bewail Maw's fate, in styles ranging from Scottish country dance to serious blues; while a screen above the fireplace alternates between a sentimental Highland scene, and captioned texts in which the great philosophers of post-modernity offer their thoughts on the journey of the individual towards self-knowledge.
It has to be said that having set up this brilliant and hilarious scenario, Jackie Kay's 90-minute script doesn't quite develop the dramatic momentum of which it might have been capable. The relationship between the two Maw Broons is not clear; the idea of the black alter ego is not developed, and their conversation often dwindles into daytime television cliché. The show expresses no legible view about the self-obsessed individualism of our time; and it often slides into the easy comic option of setting up the old tenement stereotype, and then raising cheap laughs by conjuring up incongruities, like Maw Broon serving up sashimi.
But if the show sometimes lacks focus, and often tends to reinforce the stereotypes it sets out to challenge, it's also one of the most hilariously inventive investigations of Scottish kitsch culture to appear on stage since the 1980s. Maggie Kinloch's production fully exploits the postmodern madness of the material; Neason and Bonnar both sing beautifully, particularly when it comes to the blues. And Neason in particular sometimes seems like the very embodiment of a certain kind of Scottish womanhood – the hard-working, self-mocking kind for whom being a woman was never a matter of pride or joy, and who therefore needed the liberation brought by the strange, self-centred times we live in, as much as any group on earth.
Theatre reviews: The Maw Broon Monologues
Maw Broon, catching up after 60 years in limbo with everything the 21st century has to offer.
Date: 05 November 2009
By Joyce McMillan
THE MAW BROON MONOLOGUES ****
TRON THEATRE, GLASGOW
FOR a woman who first saw the light of day on 8 March 1936 – and was a lusty 50-year-old even then – the Sunday Post's great Scottish cartoon matriarch, Maw Broon, is looking in pretty good shape. She's not slim, she's not young, she's not braw; and as she comes to realise, in the course of The Maw Broon Monologues, a new Glasgay! Commission by Glasgow-born poet and playwright Jackie Kay, she isn't actually real.
For all her disadvantages, though, Maw Broon – as personified here by fabulous Terry Neason, and black alter ego Suzanne Bonnar – is all woman; and in Kay's weird, slightly mind-blowing tartan-tinged fantasy, she takes umbrage at Paw Broon's suspected infidelity, and sets off from her kitsch room-and-kitchen at No 10 Glebe Street to travel the world of the early 21st century, in search of the personal fulfilment she deserves.
Tartan shopping bag in hand, and headscarf tied firmly in place, she therefore visits a shrink, tries colonic irrigation, pines for a room of her own, wins through to round three of Scotland's Got Talent ("reality's no just on TV, ye know"), discusses the possible merits of a gay lifestyle, and generates her own version of the Vagina Monologues. And meantime, at the piano, the astonishing Tom Urie – in the character of Maw's unattractive bearded daughter, Daphne Broon – rattles out his own cycle of songs in which Neason and Bonnar celebrate or bewail Maw's fate, in styles ranging from Scottish country dance to serious blues; while a screen above the fireplace alternates between a sentimental Highland scene, and captioned texts in which the great philosophers of post-modernity offer their thoughts on the journey of the individual towards self-knowledge.
It has to be said that having set up this brilliant and hilarious scenario, Jackie Kay's 90-minute script doesn't quite develop the dramatic momentum of which it might have been capable. The relationship between the two Maw Broons is not clear; the idea of the black alter ego is not developed, and their conversation often dwindles into daytime television cliché. The show expresses no legible view about the self-obsessed individualism of our time; and it often slides into the easy comic option of setting up the old tenement stereotype, and then raising cheap laughs by conjuring up incongruities, like Maw Broon serving up sashimi.
But if the show sometimes lacks focus, and often tends to reinforce the stereotypes it sets out to challenge, it's also one of the most hilariously inventive investigations of Scottish kitsch culture to appear on stage since the 1980s. Maggie Kinloch's production fully exploits the postmodern madness of the material; Neason and Bonnar both sing beautifully, particularly when it comes to the blues. And Neason in particular sometimes seems like the very embodiment of a certain kind of Scottish womanhood – the hard-working, self-mocking kind for whom being a woman was never a matter of pride or joy, and who therefore needed the liberation brought by the strange, self-centred times we live in, as much as any group on earth.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)